The Manager’s Dilemma: Balancing Confidentiality with Team Dynamics When Supporting Domestic Abuse Survivors

Support at work

You’re doing the right thing. You’re supporting a team member through one of the most difficult experiences of their life. You’ve put workplace adjustments in place, you’re being flexible and compassionate, and you’re maintaining their confidentiality to keep them safe.

But now other team members are noticing.

They are asking questions. They are frustrated about what looks like special treatment. The workload is falling unevenly, and you are caught in the middle, unable to explain, unable to defend your decisions, and feeling like you cannot win.

If this sounds familiar, you are not alone. This is one of the most challenging situations managers face when supporting someone experiencing domestic abuse.

To help you hold onto something clear when you are stressed or overwhelmed, I want to offer you a simple framework you can come back to.

The CARE Framework

When you are managing this situation, think CARE:

C: Confidentiality

Protect their safety and privacy. You cannot share their situation without consent.

A: Adjustments

Put in place the workplace adjustments they need to stay safe and able to work.

R: Redistribution

Manage workload fairly across the team so the impact is not falling on one or two people.

E: Expectations

Set and communicate clear expectations with the team about flexibility, fairness and how concerns will be handled.

You will not get this perfect. But if you keep coming back to CARE, you will be focusing on the right things.

The Impossible Position

When you are supporting someone experiencing domestic abuse, you are often pulled between:

  • Your duty of care to the person experiencing abuse
  • Your responsibility to maintain confidentiality
  • Your obligation to manage the whole team fairly
  • The reality that others are picking up extra work
  • Your own wellbeing

There is no solution that makes everyone happy. The aim is to make it manageable and safe, not perfect.

What People See (and Do Not See)

From the team’s point of view, they may see:

  • Someone working from home more often
  • Late arrivals and early finishes
  • Flexible hours that do not seem available to everyone
  • Extra workload falling on them
  • What looks like favouritism

What they do not see is:

  • The courage it took to disclose
  • The fear and instability at home
  • Court hearings, solicitor appointments and housing searches
  • Safety planning and risk assessments
  • That these adjustments are essential, not a perk

The person experiencing abuse may feel vulnerable, guilty about the impact on colleagues, worried about their situation being revealed and under pressure to get back to normal.

You may feel stuck, frustrated, worried about both safety and morale, exhausted, and unsure if you are getting it right.

Everyone’s feelings are valid. That is what makes this so complex.

Why This Gets Harder Over Time

Domestic abuse support is rarely short term. Court processes, housing and rebuilding a life all take time. Adjustments you thought might last a few weeks can easily continue for months.

If your team is already stretched, even small changes create big ripples. Someone working from home two days a week means someone else is covering urgent queries or staying late.

In a supportive culture, people may be more understanding. In a pressured environment, this can quickly become a flashpoint, and much of it lands on you.

Practical Strategies Using CARE

1. Prepare before it becomes a crisis (C and A)

As soon as you start making adjustments, think ahead:

  • How long might these adjustments realistically need to continue?
  • What is the impact on workload?
  • Can you redistribute work proactively?
  • Do you need temporary support?
  • Who else needs to know, with consent, to help manage this?

Planning ahead reduces firefighting, even if it does not remove all the difficulty.

2. Have a general team conversation about flexibility (E)

You can normalise adjustments without mentioning anyone.

You might say:

“I want to talk about workplace adjustments and flexibility. As a team, we support each other through difficult times, whether that is health issues, family emergencies or personal circumstances.

Sometimes I will make adjustments for team members that will not be visible to everyone, but this support is available to any of you if you need it. These decisions are not made lightly, and they are always for good reasons. If you are ever struggling, please come and talk to me.”

This reinforces that flexibility is part of how you work, not favouritism.

3. Separate the two concerns when someone complains (R and E)

When a team member raises fairness, they are usually talking about:

  1. Perceived special treatment
  2. Extra workload

Treat them separately.

For the special treatment concern:

“I understand it might feel like inconsistent treatment, but I cannot discuss individual circumstances. What I can say is that workplace adjustments are made when they are needed, and they are available to anyone on the team who requires them. This is not about favouritism, it is about supporting people through difficult circumstances. I would do the same for you if you needed it.”

For the workload concern:

“You are right that workload distribution is an issue, and that is on me to manage properly. Let’s talk about what is specifically falling on you and how we can address that. What tasks are creating extra work for you at the moment?”

Example dialogue with a frustrated team member

Team member:

“It just feels like some people get to do what they want and the rest of us have to pick up the slack.”

Manager:

“I hear that you are feeling the impact of extra work, and that matters. I cannot talk about anyone’s personal situation, but I can say that adjustments are made for good reasons and are available to everyone if needed. What I would like to do is look with you at what is on your plate and where the pressure is highest, so we can see what needs to change.”

Team member:

“Most of the urgent calls are coming to me now, and I am staying late most days.”

Manager:

“Thank you for being honest about that. Let’s map out those tasks and see what we can reassign or pause. I do not want you burning out because of this.”

4. Keep the individual informed (C and A)

Be honest with the person you are supporting:

“The adjustments we have put in place are staying. You need this support and it is the right thing to do. I also want you to know that some team members have noticed changes to your working pattern and have raised questions about fairness. I have not disclosed anything about your situation, and I will not.

I wanted to check in with you about how you feel about this, and whether there is anything we need to adjust or talk through.”

This keeps them informed and gives them a say in what happens next.

5. Look for creative solutions to workload (R)

Confidentiality is non-negotiable. Workload is where you can act. Could you:

  • Offer flexible working options more widely, where appropriate?
  • Bring in temporary support?
  • Redistribute work more formally so it is not always the same people picking up extra?
  • Pause or delay lower priority tasks?

You may not be able to fix everything, but you can reduce pressure.

You might say to the team:

“We have had a few changes to working patterns recently, so I want to review how work is shared. Over the next week I will be speaking with each of you about your current workload so we can rebalance where needed. If you feel you are consistently picking up extra, please tell me so we can address it.”

What Not To Do

When you feel defensive or under pressure, it can be tempting to:

  • Hint at the person’s situation
  • Defend them personally
  • Dismiss concerns as a lack of compassion
  • Compare everyone’s problems

Avoid this. It risks breaching confidentiality and invalidating real concerns.

Stick to what you can share:

  • Adjustments are made when needed
  • They are available to everyone
  • You cannot discuss individual circumstances
  • You take workload concerns seriously and will act on them

Culture, Policy and Training

This dilemma shows why a domestic abuse policy and regular training matter.

When people understand that domestic abuse can affect anyone, that adjustments may be essential for safety, and that confidentiality is critical, they are more likely to trust that there are good reasons for decisions, even when they do not know the details.

If you do not yet have a domestic abuse policy or your team has not had training recently, this is a good time to start.

Looking After Yourself

You are holding confidential information, managing competing needs and knowing you cannot make everyone happy. It is natural to second guess yourself.

Remember:

  • You do not have to manage this alone. Speak to HR or your own manager for support, without sharing personal details.
  • You cannot please everyone, and that is not a sign you are failing.
  • Your priority is safety and support for the person experiencing abuse, while managing the team as fairly as you can.
  • It is okay to acknowledge that this is difficult.

You may need to debrief with someone who understands, access support or supervision, set boundaries around your own capacity, and accept that some people may remain unhappy.

Supporting someone through domestic abuse while managing a team is one of the hardest things you will do as a manager. Be kind to yourself.

You Are Making a Difference

If you are in this situation right now, the person you are supporting might not be able to tell you how much your support means. They may be too overwhelmed or focused on survival.

But your willingness to make adjustments, protect their confidentiality and hold the discomfort of team complaints without exposing them makes a real difference.

You are creating a safe space at work when other parts of their life feel unsafe. You are showing them that they matter, that they deserve support, and that they are not alone.

If you need support implementing a domestic abuse policy in your workplace, or training for your management team, I am here to help. You can book a free no obligation call here.

Share it